Chuck Dismisses Panton’s Criticisms


Opposition Spokesman on Justice, Delroy Chuck, is refuting a suggestion by the President of the Court of Appeal, Justice Seymour Panton, that many of those who are opposed Jamaica’s full subscription to the Caribbean Court of Justice, CCJ, are being influenced by a former legislator.

Justice Panton, made the comment last Friday during a luncheon at the Grand Palladium Hotel in Hanover.

He says those who are against the replacement of the UK based Privy Council with the CCJ are misguided and want Jamaica to be forever dependent on England for justice.

Justice Panton suggested that JLP parliamentarians are being infleunced in their stance on the CCJ, by an unnamed former legislator.

This is what he told the Cornwall Bar Association last Friday.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]

That’s being rejected by the Opposition Spokesman on Justice, Delroy Chuck.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]

During his address, Justice Panton noted that Jamaica cannot remain dependent on the UK, whose commitment to Jamaica is motivated only by self-interest.

Mr. Chuck says the JLP has been consistent that if the Privy Council is to be replaced, then it must be by a final Jamaican court.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]

In his address, Justice Panton, argued that of the three branches of Government, the judiciary has been the most outstanding, performer since Independence 53 years ago. Yet it has received only weak support from those attorneys who sit in parliament.

Mr. Chuck agrees with him.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]


2 thoughts on “Chuck Dismisses Panton’s Criticisms

  1. chikV2Ebola

    If we all agree that the Judiciary is doing a fantastic job under less than desirable circumstances .it’s time to give them additional responsibilities by establishing our final Court Of Appeal !

  2. chikV2Ebola

    We have come of age and should start taking charge of the heights of our economy and justice system. why did Jamaica became independent in the first place ? it can’t be to outsource the management of our economy and justice system !

Comments are closed.