One of the attorneys representing Vybz Kartel and his co-appellants told the Court of Appeal this morning that trial Judge, Justice Lennox Campbell, didn’t give due consideration to Kartel’s unsworn statement.

In that statement, Kartel claimed he didn’t kill Clive ‘Lizard’ Williams. The defense attorneys who presented today said Justice Campbell made other errors in his summation of the trial.

It was also claimed that shoddy police work contaminated the case.

Kartel, Andre St. John, Kahira Jones and Shawn Storm, were found guilty in April 2014 of murdering Clive ‘Lizard’ Williams at a house in Havendale St. Andrew.

Oswest Senior Smith, who’s representing Andre St John, contends that Justice Lennox Campbell diluted the strength of Kartel’s unsworn statement during his summation of the trial.

Mr. Smith repeated Kartel’s statement in which he said he ‘didn’t kill Mr. Williams’ nor did he tell someone to kill Mr. Williams.

While speaking in court, Mr. Smith said Justice Campbell didn’t give due focus to this statement in his summation to “the detriment of Kartel”.

Mr. Smith told the media after court today, he argued that the jurors in the matter needed better direction from the court in reaching their verdict.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]

In addition, Mr Smith says Justice Campbell prejudiced Mr. St. John’s case when he summarized all the cases of the accused, in one.

Mr. Smith also says from the outset a distinction should have been made for both Jones and St. John.

[audio_mp3 url=”″]

Meanwhile, the attorney representing, Kahira Jones, Robert Fletcher, is contending that the agents of the State who gave support to the case against his client were ‘loose, lax and inept’ in their handling of the matter.

He says this forced the prosecution to ‘roll out’ what he described as a contaminated case that led the trial judge into management confusion’.

Mr. Fletcher also argued that his client’s sentencing was ‘manifestly excessive’. He says Justice Campbell didn’t take a social inquiry report into consideration before handing down the sentence.

The defence attorneys ended their submissions Thurdsay. The Crown will respond in the Court of Appeal on Friday.